Skip to Content

5 Popular Sleep Training Methods And How to Choose the Best One for Your Baby

Learn about some of the most popular sleep training methods there are to help your baby learn how to fall asleep independently. See the differences between the methods and decide which sleep training method is right for your family.

baby sleeping

Good sleep is so important!

If you’re experiencing sleep deprivation as a new parent (or a seasoned parent), than sleep training can help you get your baby to sleep, meaning you get more rest too.

I think the term sleep training gets a really bad rap. After all, we all potty train our children, meaning we teach them how to use the toilet so they aren’t in diapers forever.

Sleep training isn’t a whole lot different. Parents use various sleep training methods to help them stop nursing to sleep, moving from room sharing to the crib, and transitioning from SNOO to crib.

As a Pediatric Sleep Consultant, I have walked many families through the process of sleep training their little one and helping their whole family get a good night’s sleep.

If you’re ready to leave sleepless nights behind you, then let’s dive into what sleep training is, why you might consider sleep training your baby or toddler, and the best sleep training methods.

Is your baby struggling with short naps? To help you better, grab my free guide to solving short naps to get practical tips of how to get your baby to take longer naps every single day. Click here to grab it, it’ll be super helpful.

baby boy sleeping

What is Sleep Training?

Sleep training is simply the process of teaching your little one how to fall asleep on her own, and how to sleep for longer stretches at night. Sleep training is a great way to stop nursing to sleep and weaning night feeds.

There are plenty of misconceptions and mistakes when it comes to sleep training.

Sleep training should be a holistic approach, partnered with appropriate baby wake windows, a consistent bedtime routine, a nursery that is setup for sleeping, and a sleep training method that slowly fades out the parental presence over time.

Many people equate sleep training with cry it out, but there are many different methods of sleep training, ranging from “cry it out” methods where the baby is left to cry until they fall asleep, to more gentle methods that involve gradually reducing the level of assistance provided.

The goal with sleep training is to help babies learn healthy sleep habits, improve their overall sleep quality, and reduce the need for parents to constantly intervene during the night.

little girl sleeping with caregiver holding her hand

When Should You Start Sleep Training?

Wondering when to start sleep training?

The best answer is to start sleep training when you are ready.

Formal sleep training can start as early as your baby hitting four months or 12 pounds. At four months, sleep habits aren’t too established and will be easier to break. Before four months old, many babies still have irregular feeds and need to eat in the middle of the night.

Many parents decide to sleep train when they are ready to transition baby to a crib. Moving to a crib in their nursery is when many babies need to learn independent sleep habits.

Other times parents sleep train if their baby is going through a sleep regression or they’re dealing with short naps.

Even before you do any sleep training, you can help establish healthy sleep habits like following an eat / wake / sleep routine and avoiding sleep associations. We followed a modified version of the Babywise method from birth and never had to formally sleep train our daughter.

baby sleeping in a crib

Different Sleep Training Methods

There are multiple sleep training methods out there, each with its own pros and cons. Some include a parent staying in the child’s room during sleep training, while others have the parent completely out of the room.

Some of them may involve more crying, while other methods are designed to minimize tears.

Let’s explore some of the most popular sleep training methods, including cry it out (extinction), graduated extinction, the Ferber method, bedtime fading, pick-up-put-down, and the chair method.

By understanding the differences between these methods, you can choose the one that is best suited to your baby’s needs and your own parenting style.

mom holding awake baby and smiling at him

Pick Up / Put Down

The Pick Up Put Down Method is a popular sleep training method founded by Tracy Hogg, the author of Secrets of the Baby Whisperer. Pick up / put down (PU/PD) is one of the more gentle sleep training methods there is, because you are there to physically comfort your baby by picking her up through the process.

Pick Up Put Down is recommended for babies 4 months–8 months.

With Pick Up Put Down, you do your baby’s bedtime routine and put your baby in her crib or bassinet while she is still awake.

Once your baby starts crying, you pick her up and comfort her until she calms down or her cry lessens. Once she’s calmed down a little—but not asleep—you put her back in her crib or bassinet.

Keep doing this cycle until your baby falls asleep, picking her up and putting her down as many times as needed.

Make sure you don’t hold your baby to the point of her falling asleep. The goal with Pick Up Put Down is to comfort your baby until she calms down, but then to let her fall asleep on her own in her crib or bassinet.

If your baby wakes in the middle of the night you repeat Pick Up Put Down until she falls asleep again.

Pick Up Put Down is one of the sleep training techniques that can take the longest to see results. Because it has so much parental involvement, it can be more stimulating for babies and take longer to work than other sleep training techniques.

It can take over 100 pick-ups or up to 2 hours before the child is able to fall asleep, which can be incredibly exhausting for new parents, both emotionally and physically.

However, this method can work really well for very young babies, and parents who want to stay and comfort their child consistently.

Chair in baby's nursery to sleep train using the Sleep Lady Shuffle

The Sleep Lady Shuffle

The Sleep Lady Shuffle, also referred to as the Chair Method, can be used for babies as young as four months, all the way up to toddlerhood. It can be especially helpful for toddler sleep training as a way to keep your toddler in their bed at bedtime.

Many parents like using this because it is considered a gentle sleep training method.

With this sleep training method, you physically stay in the room as your child falls asleep, but you aren’t picking her up again and again. You sit in a chair and will gradually fade your presence out of the room over the course of several days.

Do your typical bedtime routine and put your baby to bed awake. Make sure the room is dark, so your baby can’t see you. Have a chair ready next to your baby’s crib or bassinet.

If your baby starts to cry or fuss, you sit in the chair while she stays in her crib or bed.

Your presence in the chair can help your baby or toddler stay calm in their sleep space and help them fall asleep, knowing that you are there.

You can choose a simple word or phrase to say to help soothe your baby. Something short and simple like, “Shh” or “Mommy’s here” is perfect.

When your baby starts to cry or fuss you can use your word or phrase in a hushed tone to help soothe her. Keep it simple and short so you aren’t bringing on additional stimulation.

You can also pat your baby, but the goal is to not pick her up out of the crib.

Once your baby falls asleep, you leave the room.

If your child wakes up in the middle of the night, resume your position in the chair and repeat for night wakings until she falls asleep again. You’ll do this every time she wakes up. (So grab a comfortable chair!)

Repeat this same process with the chair in the same spot for three consecutive days. After three days, you move your chair further away.

If you started with the chair right next to the crib, you would move it halfway between the door and the crib. At this point you won’t be able to physically reassure your baby, but continue to use your word or phrase to soothe her with your voice.

Once you move the chair further away, it’s important to not go back to a prior position. Every three days you will move the chair further away until it is outside of your baby’s room.

Your baby will learn to put herself to sleep during this process, while still knowing that mom or dad is there. Eventually she won’t need your voice at all to fall asleep!

It’s also a great sleep training method to use when you transition to a toddler bed or in combination with the Pacifier Fairy when you drop the pacifier with your toddler!

Baby standing in crib during sleep training

The Gentle Three-Minute Drill

The gentle-three minute drill is a favorite among many parents and sleep consultants because it allows the parents to be involved, without requiring the constant involvement that Pick Up Put Down and the Chair Method require.

This method works well for any baby in a crib and allows for some crying before a caregiver checks in and consoles their baby.

How to Do the Gentle Three-Minute Drill

As always, do your bedtime routine and put your baby down for bed while she is still awake.

Leave the room. You are going to stay outside of the room and listen to your baby. She may cry and fuss a little bit and then fall asleep.

If your baby cries, listen for the cry to elevate to a loud level-10 cry. This is the cry that says “I want outta here!” but isn’t the cry your baby has when she is hurt or in pain.

Once your baby starts to cry at this level, start the timer for three minutes.

It might feel like an eternity at first mama!

If at any point during your baby’s cry, she simmers down to a whimper, you stop your timer. You then restart it when the cry elevates to that level-10 cry again.

As your baby simmers down and her cry lowers, she is learning to self-soothe! So while I’m sure you just want that timer to run out so you can rush into her room, it is actually a good thing if you need to stop and restart your timer frequently!

After three consecutive minutes of that level-10 cry, you can stop the timer and go into your baby’s room and soothe her.

When you go into her room give her a little reassurance and comfort. You can offer a soothing “Shhh” or “Mommy’s here.” You can give her a little pat on her bottom, but try to avoid picking her up from her crib. I know this will be tough, but stick with it!

Keep it short, about 10 to 20 seconds and then leave the room again.

Restart your timer and repeat the process until your baby falls asleep. If your baby wakes up in the middle of the night, you will start your timer and repeat the process again.

little girl standing up in her crib smiling

Controlled Crying

Controlled crying is also known as Interval Crying, Ferber Method, or Ferberizing. It’s been popularized by Richard Ferber’s book, Solve Your Child’s Sleep Problems. It is good for children in a crib and has the parent check in through increasing intervals.

To do Controlled Crying, choose an interval time that you are comfortable with. This is how long you will let your baby cry before going into her room. Common interval options are 5 / 7 / 10 and 5 / 10 / 15.

It’s okay to start on the lower end in the beginning. I have even had some families do 3 / 5 / 7.

Do your typical bedtime routine and put your baby down for bed awake.

Leave the room and listen close by. Once your baby starts crying at that level-10 cry, set your timer for your first interval.

For our example, we’ll do 5 / 10 / 15. At baby’s level-10 cry, set your timer for 5 minutes and keep it going. You will go into your baby’s room at the end of the five minutes regardless, unless she has stopped crying or settled down.

After five minutes, go in and reassure your baby. Don’t pick her up but offer her a verbal phrase. Keep your visit short and just offer a quick reassurance, then leave the room again.

This time you will increase your timer. For our example, we’ll now set the timer to 10 minutes. At the end of the 10 minutes, if your baby hasn’t fallen asleep or calmed down, you can go into her room again and do another short reassurance with words.

After you leave her room again, set your timer for the third interval, 15 minutes for this example. If your baby is still crying after 15 minutes, go into her room for a short reassurance again.

If she continues to cry, you can reset your timer to 15 minutes and offer quick reassurance after 15 minutes each time.

If your baby wakes up in the middle of the night, start your process again at 5 minutes and repeat the cycle from there.

Baby standing in crib upset during sleep training

Cry It Out / Extinction Method

Cry it out, also known as extinction method, is the least gentle of the sleep training methods. Some may consider it cruel, but for others, the crying is short and works quickly. This method typically involves the most crying and has the least amount of parental presence.

Extinction sleep training is simple to follow, but can be very emotionally difficult on the parents. You follow your same bedtime routine with your baby and then put her to bed and leave the room. You don’t return until the morning.

Some babies will stop crying quickly and fall asleep, while others may cry for very long periods of time. This is usually the last-resort for sleep training, when other methods haven’t worked.

mom holding baby in her arms

Which Sleep Training Method is Best?

There is no one-size-fits-all approach when it comes to parenting. We all have unique personalities, and our little babies are no different. Even from a very young age, babies have different temperaments and will respond better to certain methods over others.

Different sleep training methods work best for different families. The best sleep training method for you will depend on your baby’s temperament, as well as your personality as a parent.

In addition to your baby’s personality, you should consider your preference when sleep training.

Is hearing your baby cry for long periods of time really difficult for you? Do you want to stay in the room to help soothe your baby through the sleep training process.

It’s a good idea to choose a sleep training method that you and your partner are comfortable with and can sustain over the course of 2 to 3 weeks.

baby sleeping with his arms out

What is the Most Effective Sleep Training Method?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to what the most effective sleep training method is. Every baby (and parent) is different, and will respond differently to different approaches. 

Some parents find Check and Console methods to be very effective in quickly teaching babies to self-soothe, while others prefer the more hands-on approach of the Chair Method. 

Ultimately, the effectiveness of a sleep training method depends on several factors, including your baby’s age, temperament, routines, and consistency. 

It’s important for parents to choose a method that aligns with their values and beliefs, and to be extremely consistent in implementing the method. 

toddler sleeping with a teddy bear

What Age is Easiest to Sleep Train?

There are pros and cons to sleep training at any age.

Some things will be easier about sleep training a younger baby and some things will be easier about sleep training a toddler.

It’s important to consider your own readiness for sleep training. Starting sleep training too early or before you feel prepared can lead to unnecessary stress and frustration for both you and your baby.

Make sure to take your own comfort level into account when deciding when to sleep train.

baby boy sleeping in a crib

Tips for Successful Sleep Training

There is so much more to sleep training than just choosing a method. Sleep training is a holistic approach, and you likely won’t see success unless you have all the elements working together.

Here are tips for successful sleep training, in addition to choosing your sleep training method.

Create a conducive sleep environment

One of the easiest things to do before sleep training is create an environment that is conducive for sleep. 

Some things you can do to create a good sleep environment include keeping the room dark, quiet, and cool, using white noise to drown out any outside noise, and using blackout curtains to prevent any outside light from coming in.

Follow Your Baby’s Sleep Schedule

When doing any of these sleep training methods, make sure you’re following your baby’s proper wake windows and that you aren’t putting your baby to bed overtired.

Establish a bedtime routine

Establishing a consistent bedtime routine for your baby can be so helpful when sleep training. A bedtime routine helps signal to your baby that it is time for sleep.

A bedtime routine can consist of 3 to 5 activities that helps your baby get ready for bed, such as a bath, books, and a song. The key is to keep the routine consistent every night, so your baby starts to know what to expect and associates their routine with sleep.

mom holding baby in her arms

Start At Night

Start at night time: Note that night time sleep training is different than daytime sleep training. Start at bedtime to see the best results and start sleep training for naps after bedtime starts getting easier.

Be consistent

Consistency is key when it comes to sleep training. Once you have established your sleep training method and bedtime routine, stick with it. Consistency can help your baby learn what is coming next and help them develop healthy sleep habits.

Monitor your baby’s progress

It’s easy to get discouraged, but map out your progress so that you can measure data and see how things are going. Sleep training won’t always be linear, but you should see general forward progress over a few weeks.

Be Patient

Sleep training can take time, so be patient and remember that every baby is different. How long sleep training takes depends on your baby’s temperament, the method chosen, and consistency.

Common Concerns About Sleep Training

Many parents have concerns about sleep training, such as whether it is harmful to baby, or if it will affect attachment. However, research shows that sleep training is safe and does not harm babies. In fact, many parents find that their bond with their baby actually improves once they start getting better sleep.

Sleep training can be a challenging process, but it can also be incredibly rewarding. By picking the right sleep training method for your family and staying consistent, you can help your baby learn to fall asleep on their own and get everyone better sleep.

Baby D.R.E.A.M Mockup image

Get Better Sleep with The Baby D.R.E.A.M. System

If you want someone to walk you through the process of sleep training, let me help. The Baby D.R.E.A.M. System is for babies 4 months through 2.5 years old. I’ll walk you through how to establish daily routines, sleep schedules, and sleep training techniques to help you break the sleep associations you no longer find beneficial! Check it out here.

Amy Motroni

How to Help Your Reflux Baby Sleep - The Postpartum Party

Friday 21st of May 2021

[…] It just means that you’ll need to get their reflux symptoms under control before you try a sleep training method that requires your baby to fall asleep […]